BLD20160408_Certificate_of_Appropriateness.pdfPRESENTATION BY PATRICK DOH'ERTYCOMMUNITY SERVICESIECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
DIRECTOR ON MAIN STREET PROGRAM AND BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT Bip
Mr. Doherty introduced himself and briefly reviewed his history and background. He advised that the intent of the Main
Street Program, which is under the purview of the National Parks Service, and specifically the National Trust for Historic
Preservation, is to recognize the historic cores of America's towns and villages; encourage revitalization, rehab and reuse of
historic buildings; and encourage more vibrant town life centered around the historic character of the community. He briefly
reviewed the four points of the program (organization, promotion, design and economic restructuring) and its eight guiding
principles.
Mr. Doherty observed that the community of Edmonds is defined by the City's historic core and traditional downtown, which
has become the standard bearer of the character of the City. He reviewed the rigorous and broad designation criteria outlined
in the program, noting that designation takes hard work and commitment by the entire community. He specifically referred
to Washington State's Main Street Program, which offers several levels of association. He announced that, as of yesterday,
the City of Edmonds is now an "affiliate community" of the Main Street Program. While this is an extremely minor
accomplishment, it allowed the City to apply to host the Washington State Trust for Historic Preservation's Revitalized Walk
Conference next May. The application was supported by the Snohomish County Tourism Bureau and the City of Snohomish,
which has offered to provide: a torn` to participants. He noted that the City will celebrate its 125`h anniversary in 2015. If the
City is selected to host the conference, it is hoped that downtown property owners will find added interest in "sprucing" up
their buildings.
Mr. Doherty said that, in his opinion, the City does not need to establish another nonprofit group to administer a Main Street
Program. He reviewed that the City already has a historic ordinance in place that works well, It also has a high level of
organisation via the Business Improvement District (BID) and Downtown I,dtnonds Merchant's Association (DEMA).
Commissioner Deiner-Karr said she reached the same conclusion after attending the National Trust for Historic Preservation
Conference, which focused on the Main Street Program. Commissioner Allbery said Mr. Doherty's recommendation is
consistent with that of the South Snohomish County Historical Society, as well.
If the City is selected to host the Washington State Trust for Historic Preservation's Revitalized Walk Conference, the
Commission discussed using the event as leverage to get more of the historic downtown properties on the Edmonds Register
of Historic Places. For example, Commissioner Tays said he has had numerous discussions with the Edmonds Arts Center
Board, but they still have not decided whether to move forward with an application or not. The Commissioners agreed it is
important to inform the City Council and the public that the City is now an affiliate of the Main Street Program. They also
agreed that the City should continue to consider opportunities for additional participation in the program, perhaps in
conjunction with an existing program and/or organization.
APPROI WAT' fNI+
OF
CERTIFICATE
d I� SS ItFLAT'LIi TO PROPOSED CHANGES I»!tDlt "I'IIE RELIABLE FLOOR
BUILDING
Mr. Chave explained that the owners of the Reliable Floor Building are proposing new signage, which requires a Certificate
of Appropriateness because the building is on the Edmonds Register of Historic Places.
Clayton Moss, Architect, provided several photographs and described the proposed design for the new sign, which consists
of a logo and individual letters with brackets.
The Commission recalled previous concern about recent siding changes. Commissioner Scott noted that because there are no
pictures of the original siding (it was previously plywood), the property owner decided to use shingle siding to represent
Edmonds' heritage of shingle mills. Mr. Moss expressed his opinion that the shingle siding has been overused. While it is
okay on the fagade, using it on the canopy results in a mansard roof appearance that was popular in the 1980s. He suggested
that a more traditional siding could be used on the canopy.
COMMISSIONER SCOTT MOVED THAT THE COMMISSION APPROVE A CERTIFICATE OF
APPROPRIATENESS FOR THE' PROPOSED SIGN CHANGES. COMMISSIONER DIEINER-KARR
SECONDED THE MOTION.
Historic''Prescrv<ttion Conirnission Minutes
November 13, 2014 Page 2
The Commission discussed that although the detailed designs have not been submitted, Mr. Moss has provided enough
information for the Commission to approve the proposed sign design. It was noted that Mr. Moss intends to discuss further
details with Commissioner Wade. Mr. Moss said he would like approval for the Commission to get the sign permit moving
forward. If necessary, additional construction details can be presented to the Commission at a later time.
THE MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
CONTINUED INTRODUCTION OF NEW COMMISSIONERS
At the request of Chair Tays, Commissioner Livingston introduced himself and provided a brief overview of his history and
background.
COMMITTEE REPORTS
Registration Committee
Commissioner Deiner-Karr reported that she was unable to continue her research on the Bigalow property timeline, but hopes
to get it done in the next few weeks. Chair Tays agreed to continue to work with the property owner to prepare the
nomination. Commissioner Deiner-Karr further reported that she intends to do more research on the historic house on Bell
Street and begin her research on the Yost Park Dams in early 2015.
It was discussed that new residents are living in the Mowatt House, and there is a file of information available on the home.
Commissioner Deiner-Karr agreed to find contact information on the new owners, and Chair Tays agreed to approach them
with a request that the property be added to the Register.
Commissioner Scott advised that she would send out an updated spreadsheet of properties currently on the Register, as well
as potential properties for the Register in December. She invited the Commissioners to forward their comments to her
regarding which properties they want to pursue.
Commissioner Deiner-Karr advised that she is working with representatives from the Edmonds Museum to update the
histories of buildings in downtown Edmonds. This information will be available to the Commission.
Education and Outreach Committee
Commissioner Vogel announced that the article on the Schumacher Building was published in the most recent edition of the
UPDATE EDMONDS NEWSLETTER. He was also invited to make his history presentation at Edmonds Landing, slanting
the information more towards the history of people.
Mr. Chave reported that the 2015 calendar has been sent to the press, and it should be available by November 21". The
Commission had a brief discussion about how to disseminate the calendars.
Preservation 'Planning. Colninittee
There was no report from the Preservation Planning Committee.
South Snohomish County llistot ical Societ
Commissioner Allbery reported that the historical Society announced the winners of the scarecrow festival at an event held
on 'Noveuibe�r 3`d. Total funds collected from this year's 'Ileritage Ginner were about $32,000, compared to more than
$40,000 collected at last year's event. She announced that the Edmonds Museum is currently closed as it prepares for its new
exhibit titled, "Christmas Toys." The museum will be a drop-off location for the "Toys for Tots" program.
NEW BUSINESS
The Process Before and After Receivine Applications for Re ister
Ms. Cunningham provided copies of the current process, which was drafted and approved by the Commission in 2004. The
Commission discussed whether or not the process needs to be significantly updated or if it is simply a matter of making sure
Historic Preservation Commissiorr Minutes
November 13, 2014 Page 3
IF lie. 189"j
CITY OF EDMONDS
121 5th Avenue North, Edmonds WA 98020
Phone: 425.771.0220 • Fax: 425.771.0221 • Web:wwxdmopdsw�oovv
DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DEPARTMENT • PLANNING DIVISION
CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS
Project:
Reliable Flooring Sign Permit (BLD20160408)
Location:
542 — Main Street
Property Owner:
Reliable Floors
c/o Kim Wahl
539 Main Street
Edmonds, WA 98020
Applicant:
Clayton Moss
114-4 1h Avenue North
Edmonds, WA 98020
Certificate of Appropriateness
Pursuant to Edmonds Community Development Code (ECDC) 20.45.040.13, prior to the commencement
of any work on a register property, the owner must request and receive a Certificate of Appropriateness
from the Historic Preservation Commission (HPC) for the proposed work.
Findings
1. Scope. The property owner and applicant are proposing to replace existing signs on the Reliable
Floors building (listed on the Register of Historic Places as the IOOF Hall) with three signs.
2. Significance. The IOOF Hall was listed on the Edmonds Register of Historic Places in December
2008 under Ordinance No. 3714. The exterior of the building was designated as the significant
feature.
3. Historic Preservation Commission Review. The City of Edmonds Historic Preservation
Commission reviewed the proposed signs at their regular meeting on November 13, 2014.
4. Findings. The Historic Preservation Commission found the sign did not detract from the historic
character of the former IOOF Hall unanimously approved the sign design for Reliable Flooring. The
Sign pplication under Lr 60408 is consistent with the sign reviewed by the Historic
1� - servation Commission.
Lien, Senior
April 13, 2016
Date
Page 1 of 1