Response to Bldg Comments 2 Bldg A.pdfSOUND STRUCTURAL SOLUTIONS
SSS E N G I N E E R S
9/14/2016
To: Chuck Miller
Edmonds Reviewer
Re: Correction Notice #2 (September 12, 2016)
Review Type: Plan Review
Project Address: 20732 76th Avenue W, Building A
Project #: BLD2016-0562
From: Devin Hougard, EIT
SSS#: 1603023
Thank you for your time and consideration in this matter. Here is the information,
corrections or clarifications that you requested.
1.
a. The HDR over the "plan north" window of Unit 06 has been calculated as
beam (1-24). The point load from beam (2-2) above has been accounted
for. (2)-2x6 is strong enough to carry the required load.
b. The calculation for beam (1-17) has been updated to include two point
loads from above; beam (2-6) and beam (2-22). With the point loads, the
beam has been upgraded to a 4x8 DF #2 beam.
c. The fireplace in Unit 07 has been removed to match the architectural
plans.
2. The fireplace in Unit 05 has been removed to match the architectural plans.
3. Beam (2-12) has been recalculated to include the point load from above, beam
(3-4). A 4x8 DF #2 beam is large enough to carry the load.
If you have any questions, require additional information, or believe we have
misinterpreted your requests, please call us at 425-778-1023, and we'd be happy to
discuss them.
Attached: Beam calcs, 1-24, 1-17, 2-22, 2-12
Key Plans S6, S7, S8
2411356 1h Ave W - Mountlake Terrace, WA 98043 - Ph: 425-778-1023 - Fax: 206-260-7490
Project Title:
Engineer:
Project Descr:
Title Bleck Line 6
Wood Beam
Description : 1-24
0.41& 1 Maximum Shear Stress Ratio
CODE REFERENCES
„
Calculations per NDS 2012, IBC 2012, CBC 2013, ASCE 7-10
Section used for this span
Load Combination Set: ASCE 7-10
fo : Actual =
Material Properties
fv : Actual
Design
Analysis Method: Allowable Stressg
Fb -Tension
Load Combination ASCE 7-10
Fb - Compr
= 150.00 psi
Fc • Prll
Wood Species Hem Fir
Fc - Perp
Wood Grade : No.2
Fv
0.613ft
Ft
Beam Bracing Beam is Fully Braced against lateral -torsional buckling
Span # where maximum occurs =
Project ID:
Printed: 13S., P, W 6,:37PM
File - S:1J __-
- obs�s1iz��6{S�'�"hE197'�11W(}tCO3°t11%08Gh7 � E'tr
ENERCALC, INC. 1983-2016, Build:6.16.7.21, Ver:6.16.7.21
850.0 psi
850.0 psi
1,300.0 psi
405.0 psi
150.0 psi
525.0 psi
E : Modulus of Elasticity
Ebend- xx 1, 300.0 ksi
Eminbend - xx 470.Oksi
Density 27.70 pcf
2-20
S,- ft
Applied LoadsService loads entered Load Factors will be applied for calculations.
Uniform Load : D = 0.010 ksf, Tributary Width= 8.0 ft, (WALL)
Uniform Load : D=0.010, L = 0.040 ksf, Tributary Width= 3.50 ft, (FLOOR)
Uniform Load : D=0.010, L = 0.040 ksf, Extent= 0.50 -->> 2.0 ft, Tributary Width= 5.0 ft, (FLOOR)
Uniform Load : D= 0.010 ksf, Extent= 0.50 -->> 2.0 ft, Tributary Width= 8.0 ft, (WALL)
Uniform Load : D=0.0150, S =0.0250 k/ft, Extent= 0.50-->> 2.0 ft, Tributary Width =1.0 ft, (ROOF)
Point Load : D=0.420, L = 0.60 k @ 0.50 ft, (Rxn 2-2R)
DESIGN SUMMARY NNNOM
� e �
Maximum Bending Stress Ratio =
0.41& 1 Maximum Shear Stress Ratio
= 0.736 :1
Section used for this span
2-2x6
Section used for this span
2-2x6
fo : Actual =
459.25psi
fv : Actual
= 110.37 psi
FIB: Allowable =
1,105.00psi
Fv : Allowable
= 150.00 psi
Load Combination
+D+L
Load Combination
+D+L
Location of maximum on span =
0.613ft
Location of maximum on span
= 0.000ft
Span # where maximum occurs =
Span # 1
Span # where maximum occurs
= Span # 1
Maximum Deflection
Max Downward Transient Deflection
0.004 in Ratio=
5566>=360
Max Upward Transient Deflection
0.000 in Ratio=
0 <360
Max Downward Total Deflection
0.007 in Ratio=
3212 >=240.
Max Upward Total Deflection
0.000 in Ratio=
0 <240.0
Vertical ReactionsSupport
notation : Far left is #1
Values in KIPS
.. . . ...............,... ...........
Load Combination
.---
Support 1 Support 2
...........
-Overali MA7Cimum ........,, -- �m......
..m
.... ®.833
.. 1.214 .
- ........ .......,_._
- .
Overall MINimum
0.014 0.023
+D+L
1.214 0.833
+D+S
0.526 0.379
+D+0.750L+0.750S
1.049 0.732
D Only
0.512 0.356
L Only
0.703 0.478
S Only
0.014 0.023
Project Title:
Engineer:
Project ID:
Project Descr:
Tide Block Line 6
Pnnted 14 SEP 2016 6:52AM
_ — �.....
.....,_. dile SW0bS%
1ft16031S1E797-11W01R 'ttt60802 f,LG6
Wood Beall
ENERCALG INC. 1983-2016 BwId.6.16.7.21,Ver616,7,21
�
Description : 1-17
CODE REFERENCES
Calculations per NDS 2012, IBC 2012,
CBC 2013, ASCE 7-10
Load Combination Set : ASCE 7-10
Material Properties
-
...... —.
sisMeto Allowable Design Tension900 psi
Analysis
E:Mdulusof Elasticity
Load on ASCE 0
Fb - Compr 900 psi
x 1600ksi
Fc - PrII 1350 psi
Eminbend - xx 580 ksi
Wood Species : Douglas Fir - Larch
Fc - Perp 625 psis
Wood Grade : No.2
Fv 180 psi
Ft 575 psi
Density 31.2 pcf
Beam Bracing Beam is Fully Braced against lateral -torsional buckling
_- C!a' "n rev BLMUS'
f Rte K4g3f J 4,Ru,l 5p+1D�'M1�"d',?dNdM' St0.00
4x8
Span = 3,50 ft
Applied Loads
Service loads entered Load
Factors will be applied for calculations.
_....................... pp
Uniform Load: D = 0.010 ksf, Tributary Width = 8.0 ft, (WALL)
Uniform Load: D = 0.010, L = 0.040 ksf,
Tributary Width =13.50 ft, (FLOOR)
Uniform Load : D = 0.0150, L = 0.040, S
= 0.0250 ksf, Tributary Width = 2.50 ft, (DECK)
Point Load: D = 0.5850, L = 0.960, S = 0.1880 k @ 1.667 ft, (Rxn 2-6R)
Point Load: D = 0.2570, L = 0.2870, S =
0.3080 k @ 2.750 ft, (Rxn 2-22L)
DESIGN SUMMARY
Maximum Bending Stress Ratio
0.971: 1 Maximum Shear Stress Ratio
= 0.895 :1
Section used for this span
4x8 Section used for this span
4x8
fb : Actual -
1,136.24psi fv : Actual
- 161.09 psi
FB : Allowable -
1,170.00psi Fv : Allowable
_ 180.00 psi
Load Combination
+D+L Load Combination
+D+L
Location of maximum on span _
1.673ft Location of maximum on span
- 3.500 ft
Span # where maximum occurs
Span # 1 Span # where maximum occurs
_ Span # 1
Maximum Deflection
Max Downward Transient Deflection
0.022 in Ratio= 1901 >=360
Max Upward Transient Deflection
0.000 in Ratio= 0 <360
Max Downward Total Deflection
0.033 in Ratio= 1259>=240.
Max Upward Total Deflection
0.000 in Ratio= 0 <240.0
Vertical ReactionsSupport
notation : Far left is #1
....... m._..... .._.
Values in KIPS
-------
Load Combination
_j.... S�ppo rt 2
Support
werali"N1i imum
�4$t1....... - ........
2.726'
_. .......-------------
Overall MINimum
0.274 0.441
+D+L
2.488 2.725
+D+S
1.077 1.363
+D+0.750L+0.750S
2.272 2.605
D Only
0,803 0.922
L Only
1.684 1.803
S Only
0.274 0.441
Project Title:
Engineer: Project ID:
Project Descr:
Title Blolck_Line 6 Printed 14SEP2018 B 47AM
Wood Beam...... ._-- _.. _._ _.File- �d.. s _...
- pt%b61sb6034S1E797-11W01609 160802-1 Efi�6
FNEIRC ALC, INC. 1983-2016, Build.6,16 7.21, Ver 6.167.21
Description : 2-22
0.441: 1 Maximum Shear Stress Ratio N
Section used for this span
3.5x9
Section used for this span
CODE REFERENCES
1,217.32psi
fv : Actual
FB : Allowable
2,760.00psi
Calculations per NDS 2012, IBC 2012, CBC 2013, ASCE 7-10
Load Combination
+D+S
Load Combination
Location of maximum on span -
Load Combination Set: ASCE 7-10
Location of maximum on span -
Span # where maximum occurs -
Span # 1
Span # where maximum occurs -
Material Properties_
D Only
0.257
0.109 in Ratio=
' s Design
Analysis Method: Allowable Stress
is
Fb -Teension
2400 psi
E • Modulus of Elasticity...
Max Downward Total Deflection
Load Combination ASCE 7-10
Fb - Compr
1850 psi
Ebend- xx
1800ksi
Fc - Prll
1650 psi
Eminbend - xx
950 ksi
Wood Species : DF/DF
Fc - Perp
650 psi
Ebend- yy
1600 ksi
Wood Grade :24F - V4
Fv
265 psi
Eminbend - yy
850 ksi
Ft
1100 psi
Density
31.2 pcf
Beam Bracing : Beam is Fully Braced against lateral -torsional buckling
D(1J05) S(2 815)
tD tp 01;t3:� 110.05332) ''
3.5x9
Span = 10750 ft
Applied I_—AS Service loads entered. Load Factors will be applied for calculations.
Uniform Load : D = 0.010, L = 0.040 ksf, Tributary Width = 1.333 .(.. W W...__.__.
- - ft, (FLOOR)
Point Load: D =1.705, S = 2.835 k @ 9.583 ft, (Rxn 3-51L)
DESIGN SUMMARY
Maximum Bending Stress Ratio -
0.441: 1 Maximum Shear Stress Ratio N
Section used for this span
3.5x9
Section used for this span
fb : Actual -
1,217.32psi
fv : Actual
FB : Allowable
2,760.00psi
Fv : Allowable
Load Combination
+D+S
Load Combination
Location of maximum on span -
9.573ft
Location of maximum on span -
Span # where maximum occurs -
Span # 1
Span # where maximum occurs -
Maximum Deflection
D Only
0.257
Max Downward Transient Deflection
0.109 in Ratio=
1180>=360
Max Upward Transient Deflection
0.000 in Ratio=
0 <360
Max Downward Total Deflection
0.189 in Ratio=
682>=240.
Max Upward Total Deflection
0.000 in Ratio=
0 <240.0
MEMO
"` •
0.644 :1
3.5x9
196.13 psi
304.75 psi
+D+S
10.750 ft
Span # 1
Vertical ReactionsPP
Su ort notation Far left is #1 Values inKIPS.-.� –
Load Combination
Support 1
Support 2
.....
..... .....
l�veraii ii/l'%dfimum --.. -------
_. _- ,
b.70�4:11-9�
-..-......... -- -- —.
Overall MINimum
0.257
0.287
+D+L
0.543
1.878
+D+S
0.565
4.119
+D+0.750L+0.750S
0.703
3.702
D Only
0.257
1.592
L Only
0.287
0.287
S Only
0.308
2,527
Project Title:
Engineer:
Project Descr:
Title Block Line 6 _ File
Wood Beam ..............__... ___
FI
Description : 2-12
0.971: 1 Maximum Shear Stress Ratio
Section used for this span
CODE REFERENCES
_ ....
Section used for this span
fb : Actual =
Calculations per NDS 2012, IBC 2012, CBC
2013, ASCE7-10
FIB: Allowable =
Load Combination Set: ASCE 7-10
Fv : Allowable
Load Combination
Material Properties .-------------
Load Combination
.
Analysis Method: Allowable Stres...
s Design
Fb -Tension
900.0 psi
Load Combination ASCE 7-10
Fb - Compr
900.0 psi
D Only
Fc - Prll
1,350.0 psi
Wood Species : Douglas Fir - Larch
Fc . Perp
625.0 psi
Wood Grade : No.2
Fv
180.0 psi
0.121 in Ratio=
Ft
575.0 psi
Beam Bracing Beam is Fully Braced against lateral -torsional buckling
0 <240.0
O --- .
--
_....�_.
I�GykM.t'a't3 RCO;§
7
A
A
4xe
Span = 8.0 R
Applied Loads
Uniform Load : D = 0.010 ksf, Tributary Width= 5.0 ft, (WALL)
Uniform Load: D = 0.010, L = 0.040 ksf, Tributary Width = 8.0 ft, (FLOOR)
Uniform Load: D = 0.0150, S = 0.0250 ksf, Tributary Width =1.0 ft, (ROOF)
Point Load: D = 0.920, S =1.530 k @ 1.250 ft, (Rxn 34R)
DESIGN SUMMARY
Project ID:
Printed: 14 SEP 2016, 8:41AM
INC. 19632016, Build:6.16.7.21, Ver:6.16.7.21
E: Modulus of Elasticity
Ebend- xx 1,600.0 ksi
Eminbend - xx 580.Oksi
Density 31.20pcf
Service loads entered. Load Factors will be applied for calculations,
Maximum Bending Stress Ratio =
0.971: 1 Maximum Shear Stress Ratio
Section used for this span
4x8
Section used for this span
fb : Actual =
1,306.71 psi
fv : Actual
FIB: Allowable =
1,345.50psi
Fv : Allowable
Load Combination
+D+0.750L+0.750S
Load Combination
Location of maximum on span =
1.927ft
Location of maximum on span
Span # where maximum occurs =
Span # 1
Span # where maximum occurs
Maximum Deflection
D Only
1.163
Max Downward Transient Deflection
0.053 in Ratio=
1364>=360
Max Upward Transient Deflection
0.000 in Ratio=
0 <360
Max Downward Total Deflection
0.121 in Ratio=
596>=240.
Max Upward Total Deflection
0.000 in Ratio=
0 <240.0
0.813 : 1
4x8
_ 168.36 psi
- 207.00 psi
+D+0.750L+0,750S
0.000 ft
_ Span # 1
Vertical Reactions
Su ort notation _Far le is Values in KIP
..pp
Load Combination
Support 1
Support 2
weratimlNA7�imum
2.8 8
f.14 — ..�...- ..._..--- ............. ---- ........
Overall MINimum
0.960
0.394
+D+L
2.123
1.587
+D+S
2,450
1,020
+D+0.750L+0.750S
2.848
1.642
D Only
1.163
0.627
L Only
0.960
0.960
S Only
1.286
0.394
T
0
CWrF C7 7
7
m
-IQ
a
§i334QGmll3
d�
\
a
rMnrt camww�,�x"m"ro"[t wd �,
��w�7�uaw~�wwsw�
ri
m
0
MIN
T
�xJ4
� I
I N
fl
I
k
I
� I
7 1 n
A 9
n
I L
I
I
I
I I
haw
it
�
I
....h. 44
M�1f0UWYp M" rnRIUCP M
:!I I
V L�
_...
rMnrt camww�,�x"m"ro"[t wd �,
��w�7�uaw~�wwsw�
ri
m
0
MIN