Loading...
PLN2022-0033 staff decision and attachments'r12C. 1 g9V Project: File Number: Date of Report From: CITY OF EDMONDS 121 5t" Avenue North, Edmonds WA 98020 Phone: 425.771.0220 • Fax: 425.771.0221 • Web: www.edmondswa.gov DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DEPARTMENT • PLANNING DIVISION FINDINGS, CONCLUSIONS AND DECISION Woodridge Apartment Tree Removal PLN2022-0033 June 6, 2022 Mike Clugston, AICP, Senior Planner A. Property Owner Woodridge Edmonds LLC 10500 NE 811 St Bellevue, WA 98004 B. Project Description Applicant Ralph Dobson Monarch Tree Service 7627 W Bostian Rd. Woodinville, WA 98072 One Douglas fir and two Western hemlocks are proposed to be removed from the Woodridge Apartment site. C. Findings and Conclusions 1. The Woodridge Apartment complex at 20904 — 21010 83rd Ave. W consists of 48 dwelling units in four buildings. Project design and landscaping was approved through permit PLN1978-00051 and the project was constructed in 1980. The site is zoned Multiple Residential (RM-2.4) and is surrounded by residentially -zoned and developed parcels. The apartment site is currently heavily trees and well landscaped. 2. Landscaping changes and tree removals at multifamily -zoned sites are processed as a Type I permit (staff design review of a landscape modification). Page 1 of 3 File No. PLN2022-0033 Administrative Design Review Woodbridge Apartment Tree Removal 3. The landscaping and tree standards in Chapters 20.13 and 23.10 of the Edmonds Community Development Code (ECDC) apply to this proposal. Pertinent definitions include: "Significant tree" means a tree that is at least six inches in diameter at breast height (DBH) as measured at four and one-half feet from the ground. For trees with multiple leaders at four and one-half feet height, the DBH shall be the combined cumulative total of branches greater than six inches diameter at four and one-half feet above the average grade. If a tree has been removed and only the stump remains that is below four and one-half feet tall, the size of the tree shall be the diameter of the top of the stump. [ECDC 23.10.030.R] b. "Hazard tree" means a tree that is dead, dying, diseased, damaged, or structurally defective as determined by a qualified tree professional. [ECDC 23.10.030.H] 4. According to the tree inventory and report prepared by certified arborist Ralph Dobson, 81 significant trees were inspected and three are proposed for removal: #38 (fir), 50 and 51 (hemlocks). The City's Urban Forest Planner reviewed the proposed removals and confirmed the these three trees meet the definition of 'hazard tree'. 5. Four other trees were noted in the tree inventory as being in poor health and recommended to be removed: #23, 37, 41, and 44. While not specifically proposed to be removed by the applicant, the Urban Forest Planner field -verified that those four trees do meet the definition of 'hazard tree' and therefore may also be removed as part of this permit. 6. According to the tree code, replacement is not required for the removal of hazard trees (ECDC 23.10.080.13). However, tree replacement is typically required for multifamily -zoned sites that apply for landscape modification per ECDC 20.13. In this case, however, the site is heavily treed and none of the three proposed tree removals (nor the four other trees that may be removed) are located on the edges of the site where replacement buffer landscaping would be appropriate. As a result, no replacement landscaping is required for this permit. D. Decision Based on the findings, conclusions and attachments to this report, the landscape modification design review in file PLN2022-0033 is approved with the following conditions: 1. This permit is valid for the removal trees #39, 50 and 51 as well as the four additional hazardous trees noted in the tree inventory that have been confirmed to be hazardous (#23, 37, 41, 44). 2. Replanting is not required for the removals in Condition #1. 3. Trees shall be fell onto private property. Page 2 of 3 File No. PLN2022-0033 Administrative Design Review Woodbridge Apartment Tree Removal 4. Vehicles and equipment shall be located on private property. Should it be necessary to use any portion of the City right-of-way, including the street or sidewalk, to perform any of this work then the contractor shall apply for and obtain a right-of- way construction permit in advance of starting work. A traffic control plan will be required as part of the right-of-way permit application. 5. Contractor/owner is responsible for keeping all debris on site and preventing any silt laden runoff from leaving the site and/or entering the city storm system. 6. Contractor/owner shall repair/replace any damaged sections of curb/gutter, sidewalk or other public improvements in City right-of-way per City standards that is caused by or occurs during the permitted project. 7. Contractor/owner is responsible for locating all on -site utilities and any utilities on neighboring properties that could be impacted by the tree removal. Relocation/revision/repair to any utilities may require separate permit. E. Attachments 1. Land use application 2. Cover letter 3. Arborist report 4. Tree inventory 5. Replanting plan 6. Staff technical comments F. Expiration Per ECDC 20.11.050.A, this design review decision is valid for 18 months. All approved work must be completed within that period or the decision expires unless an extension is requested per ECDC 20.11.050.13. G. Appeals Staff design review is a Type I decision which pursuant to ECDC 20.01.003.13 is subject to judicial appeal. Type I decisions may be appealed by a party of record with standing to file a land use petition in Snohomish County superior court. Such petition must be filed within 21 days after issuance of the decision, as provided in Chapter 36.70C RCW. Page 3 of 3 CITY OF EDMONDS MyBuildingPermit.com Clearing and Grading Application #1132772 - Woodridge Tree Removal Applicant First Name Last Name Company Name ralph dobson Monarch Tree Service Number Street Apartment or Suite Number E-mail Address 7627 W Bostian RD ralph.dobson@monarchlandscape.com City State Zip Phone Number Extension Woodinville WA 98072 2063006211 Contractor Company Name SIGNATURE LANDSCAPE SVCS LLC Number Street Apartment or Suite Number 8332 196th Ave NE City State Zip Phone Number Extension Redmond WA 98059 (253) 261-1911 State License Number License Expiration Date UBI # E-mail Address SIGNALS859KA 5/3/2023 BDi4QR5Rq ralph.dobson@monarchlandscape.com Project Location Number Street Floor Number Suite or Room Number 20904 83RD AVE W City Zip Code County Parcel Number EDMONDS 98020 00373600200101 Associated Building Permit Number Tenant Name Additional Information (i.e. equipment location or special instructions)_ Work Location Property Owner First Name Last Name or Company Name WOODRIDGE EDMONDS LLC Number Street Apartment or Suite Number 10500 NE 8TH ST City State Zip BELLEVUE WA 98004 Certification Statement - The applicant states: I certify that I am the owner of this property or the owner's authorized agent. If acting as an authorized agent, I further certify that I have full power and authority to file this application and to perform, on behalf of the owner, all acts required to enable the jurisdiction to process and review such application. I have furnished true and correct information. I will comply with all provisions of law and ordinance governing this type of application. If the scope of work requires a licensed contractor to perform the work, the information will be provided prior to permit issuance. Date Submitted: 4/27/2022 Submitted By: ralph dobson Attachment 1 PLN2022-0033 Page 1 of 2 i CITY OF EDMONDS MyBuildingPermit.com Clearing and Grading Application #1132772 - Woodridge Tree Removal Project Contact Company Name: Monarch Tree Service Name: ralph dobson Email: ralph.dobson@monarchlandscape.com Address: 7627 W Bostian RD Phone #: 2063006211 Woodinville WA 98072 Project Type Activity Type Scope of Work Multifamily Residential Landscaping and Hardscaping Only Tree Removal and/or Installation Project Name: Woodridge Tree Removal Description of Work: Removal of 3 Tress Project Details Tree Information Total number of trees to be removed Description (species, diameter) Location (front yard, back yard, etc.) 3 Douglas Fir 60+' 19-24 DBH Western Hemlock 45-60' 13-18" DBH Western Hemlock 31-45' 7-12" DBH Back and side Page 2 of 2 Attachment 1 PLN2022-0033 . OF tp,b v OHO MyBuildingPermitxom Jurisdiction: Edmonds Project Name: Woodridge Tree Removal Application ID: 1132772 Supplemental Name: Applicant Certification - Planning The applicant, and his/her/its heirs, and assigns, in consideration on the processing of the application agrees to release, indemnify, defend and hold the City of Edmonds harmless from any and all damages, including reasonable attorney's fees, arising from any action or infraction based in whole or part upon false, misleading, inaccurate or incomplete information furnished by the applicant, his/her/its agents or employees. The property affected by the application is in the exclusive ownership of the applicant or that the application has been submitted with the consent of all owners of the affected property. I certify, under the penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of Washington, that the information and exhibits herewith submitted are true and correct to the best of my knowledge and that I am authorized to file this application on behalf of the owner of the subject property. I do so certify. Attachment 1 PLN2022-0033 Woodridge Tree Removal Project 20912 83RD AVE W, Edmonds Washington 4-27-2022 I was contracted by the ownership group to provide a level 1 assessment of the site. I identified 2 trees 1 Douglas Fir Tree ID#38 which I has located behind the building and is sparsely foliated. I also have identified 2 hemlocks Tree ID # 50, 51. 51 has a large cavity in the lower trunk. Ralph Dobson ISA Certified Arborist TRAQ Certified Attachment 2 PLN2022-0033 Spring 2022 Arborist Report Tree Quantity: 3 April 25, 2022 Tree Care Service Address/Location Woodbridge Apartment 21006 83rd Ave W Edmonds, Washington 98026 Ilya Matvy ilya@guidepm.com Tree Care Service Billing Address Guide Property Services 400 N. 34th Street, Suite 206 Seattle, Washington 98103 MONARCH l k E E 'SEkvIC1=S Monarch Tree Services - Washington Monarch Landscape Company , Washington Ralph B. Dobson ISA certified Arborist PN-6357A TRAQ Certified ralph.dobson@monarchlandscape.com tel:206-300-6211 Species Qty Height DBH Service Douglas Fir 1 60+ 19"-24" Removal / Flush Cut #38 Western Hemlock 1 46'-60' 13"-18" Removal / Flush Cut #50 Western Hemlock 1 31'-45' 7"-12" Removal / Flush Cut #51 Proposal #375947 Page 1 Attachment 3 PLN2022-0033 ., MONARCH Woodbridge Apartment Map Satellite t Proposal #375947 r Legend(3) Western Hemlock (2) Douglas Fir (1) Keyboard shortcuts I Map data ©2022 Imagery ©2022 , Maxar Technologies, U.S. Geological Survey Terms of Use Page 2 Attachment 3 PLN2022-0033 .��`0 MONARCH S E R V I C E S Woodbridge Apartment Spring 2022 Arborist Report August 4, 2021 Pseudotsuga menziesii ID# 38 Douglas Fir Tag# 38 Height: 60+ DBH: 19"-24" Health: 20% - Critical August 4, 2021 Pseudotsuga menziesii ID# 38 Douglas Fir Tag# 38 Height: 60+ DBH: 19"-24" Health: 20% - Critical Proposal#375947 Page 3 Attachment 3 PLN2022-0033 MONARCH Woodbridge Apartment Spring 2022 Arborist Report August 4, 2021 Tsuga heterophylla ID# 50 Western Hemlock Tag# 50 Height: 46'-60' DBH: 13"-18" Health: 40% - Poor Removal / Flush Cut August 4, 2021 Tsuga heterophylla ID# 50 Western Hemlock Tag# 50 Height: 46'-60' DBH: 13"-18" Health: 40% - Poor Removal / Flush Cut August 4, 2021 Tsuga heterophylla ID# 51 Western Hemlock Tag# 51 Height: 31'-45' DBH: 7"-12" Health: 20% - Critical Removal / Flush Cut Proposal#375947 Page 4 Attachment 3 PLN2022-0033 % 40, /4W MONARCH TREE SERVICES Woodbridge Apartment Spring 2022 Arborist Report Health: 20% - Critical Removal / Flush Cut Proposal#375947 Page 5 Attachment 3 PLN2022-0033 MONARCH T R E E SE RVI C E b Woodbridge Apartment Legend(61) Douglas Fir (30) Atlas Cedar (14) Western Hemlock (12) Vine Maple (6) Bigleaf Maple (6) Red Alder (2) Pacific Madrone (2) Lodgepole Pine (2) Scouler Willow (1) Pacific Dogwood (1) Maple Species (1) Japanese Floweri... (1) Japanese Black P... (1) Afi Keyboard shortcuts Map data ©2022 Imagery ©2022 , Maxar Technologies, U.S. Geological Survey Terms of Use Attachment 4 PLN2022-0033 MONARCH TREE S E R Woodbridge Apartment Legend(81) Douglas Fir (7) Atlas Cedar (8) Western Hemlock (1) Vine Maple (1) Bigleaf Maple (0) Red Alder (0) i Pacific Madrone (1) Lodgepole Pine (1) Scouler Willow (0) Pacific Dogwood (0) Maple Species (0) Japanese Floweri... (0) Japanese Black P... (1) Terms of Use Attachment 4 PLN2022-0033 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 Species ■ Cedrus atlantica Atlas Cedar Pseudotsuga menz... Douglas Fir Pseudotsuga menz... Douglas Fir Pseudotsuga menz... Douglas Fir ■ Cedrus atlantica Atlas Cedar ■ Cedrus atlantica Atlas Cedar ■ Tsuga heterophylla Western Hemlock Pseudotsuga menz... Douglas Fir ■ Cedrus atlantica Atlas Cedar ■ Cedrus atlantica Atlas Cedar Pseudotsuga menz... Douglas Fir ■ Cedrus atlantica Atlas Cedar ■ Pinus contorta Lodgepole Pine ■ Pinus thunbergii Japanese Black Pine ■ Arbutus menziesii Pacific Madrone ■ Acer circinatum Vine Maple Pseudotsuga menz... Douglas Fir Pseudotsuga menz... Douglas Fir ■ Cedrus atlantica Atlas Cedar ■ Cedrus atlantica Atlas Cedar Health 13"-18" 80% - Good 46'-60' 7"-12" 80% - Good 31'-45' 13"-18" 80% - Good 46'-60' 13"-18" 80% - Good 46'-60' 13"-18" 80% - Good 46'-60' 13"-18" 80% - Good 46'-60' 7"-12" 60% - Fair 16'-30' 13"-18" 80% - Good 46'-60' 13"-18" 80% - Good 46'-60' 13"-18" 80% - Good 46'-60' 13"-18" 60%- Fair 46'-60' 13"-18" 80% - Good 46'-60' 7"-12" 60% - Fair 46'-60' 13"-18" 80% - Good 46'-60' 13"-18" 80% - Good 31'-45' 7"-12" 90% - Very Good 16'-30' 19"-24" 60% - Fair 60+ 19"-24" 60%- Fair 60+ 13"-18" 80% - Good 46'-60' 13"-18" 80% - Good 46'-60' MONARCH TRE E SE RVICES Objective Clearance Removal Cut 0.5" dia. / Clearance Removal Cut 1" dia. / Crown Raise - Vehicle Clearance / Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Clearance Removal Cut 0.5" dia. / Clearance Removal Cut 1" dia. / Crown Raise - Vehicle Clearance / Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Clearance Removal Cut 0.5" dia. / Clearance Removal Cut 1" dia. / Crown Raise - Vehicle Clearance / Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Clearance Removal Cut 0.5" dia. / Clearance Removal Cut 1" dia. / Crown Raise - Sidewalk Clearance / Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Clearance Removal Cut 0.5" dia. / Clearance Removal Cut 1" dia. / Crown Raise - Vehicle Clearance / Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Clearance Removal Cut 0.5" dia. / Clearance Removal Cut 1" dia. / Crown Raise - Vehicle Clearance / Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Clearance Removal Cut 1" dia. / Crown Raise -Vehicle Clearance / Monitor -Future Removal Clearance Removal Cut 1" dia. / Crown Raise / Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Clearance Removal Cut 0.5" dia. / Clearance Removal Cut 1" dia. / Crown Raise - Vehicle Clearance / Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Clearance Removal Cut 0.5" dia. / Clearance Removal Cut 1" dia. / Crown Raise - Vehicle Clearance / Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Clearance Removal Cut 1" dia. / Crown Raise / Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Clearance Removal Cut 0.5" dia. / Clearance Removal Cut 1" dia. / Crown Raise - Vehicle Clearance / Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Building Clearance / Clearance Removal Cut 0.5" dia. Clearance Removal Cut 1" dia. / Crown Raise / Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Clearance Removal Cut 1" dia. / Crown Raise / Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Attachment 4 PLN2022-0033 MONARCH T R E E SE RVI C E b Woodbridge Apartment Legend(81) Map SatelliteDouglas Fir(12) .f ' . Atlas Cedar (1) Western Hemlock (1) Jwo Vine Maple (0) w r � • � Bigleaf Maple (1) Red Alder (1) Pacific Madrone (0) • �'; _ Lodgepole Pine (0) •.. Scouler Willow (1) Pacific Dogwood (1) r a r Maple Species (1) t _ +, Japanese Floweri... (1) 36 i � Japanese Black P... (0) 34 35 38 • -1 '�- . 22 1 � 32 ._.. —_ 1 Iry 31 , 25 29 _- J • 24 26' 27 IC . I f 1.. .:. ` �•� 23 L .� If - .,. maim 40, i ❑ i_ Keyboard shortcuts Map data ©2022Imagery ©2022, Maxar Technologies Terms of Use Attachment 4 PLN2022-0033 # Species Health 21 Cedrus atlantica 13"-18" 80% - Good Atlas Cedar 46'-60' 22 Tsuga heterophylla 19"-24" 60%- Fair Western Hemlock 60+ 23 Prunus serrulata 7"-12" 0% - Dead Japanese Flowering ... 1%15' 24 Pseudotsuga menz... 19"-24" 80% - Good Douglas Fir 60+ 25 Acer macrophyllum 7"-12" 80% - Good Bigleaf Maple 16'-30' 26 Acer spp. 7"-12" 80% - Good Maple Species 16'-30' 27 Pseudotsuga menz... 19"-24" 80% - Good Douglas Fir 60+ 28 Pseudotsuga menz... 7"-12" 80% - Good Douglas Fir 46'-60' 29 Pseudotsuga menz... TAT 80% - Good Douglas Fir 46'-60' 30 Pseudotsuga menz... 7"-12" 80% - Good Douglas Fir 46'-60' 31 Pseudotsuga menz... 7"-12" 80% - Good Douglas Fir 46'-60' 32 Pseudotsuga menz... 7"-12" 80% - Good Douglas Fir 46'-60' 33 Pseudotsuga menz... 7"-12" 80% - Good Douglas Fir 46'-60' 34 Pseudotsuga menz... 19"-24" 80% - Good Douglas Fir 60+ 35 Cornus nuttallii 7"-12" 80% - Good Pacific Dogwood 31'-45' 36 Pseudotsuga menz... 7"-12" 80% - Good Douglas Fir 31'-45' 37 Pseudotsuga menz... 7"-12" 0% - Dead Douglas Fir 3V-45' 38 Pseudotsuga menz... 19"-24" 20% - Critical Douglas Fir 60+ 40 Salix scouleriana 19"-24" 80% - Good Scouler Willow 31'-45' 41 Alnus rubra 7"-12" 0% - Dead Red Alder 31'-45' MONARCH TRE E SE RVICES Objective Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Building Clearance / Clearance Removal Cut 1" dia. / Monitor -Future Removal Removal -Cut to Grade Clearance Removal Cut 1" dia. / Crown Raise / Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Removal -Cut to Grade Building Clearance / Clearance Removal Cut 0.5" dia. / Clearance Removal Cut 1" dia. Clearance Removal Cut 1" dia. / Crown Raise / Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Building Clearance / Clearance Removal Cut 1" dia. / Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Removal -Cut to Grade Removal/Flush Cut Removal -Cut to Grade Attachment 4 PLN2022-0033 MONARCH T R E E SE RVI C E b Woodbridge Apartment Legend (81) Map Satellite �"•� � - Douglas Fir(5) 0 Atlas Cedar (0) Western Hemlock (g) •> y0 Vine Maple (0) Bigleaf Maple (5) 'r +: Red Alder (1) .. . • '.�y Pacific Madrone (0) ��;, :'err �g'•a _ •►-�. •- •• Lodgepole Pine (0) • - , ' K; .� ,�" _'/ . Scouler Willow (0) Pacific Dogwood (0) f• �— Maple Species (0) Japanese Floweri... (0) .!:•J r. r 45 •� Y `dy '4t:>. E� : , •� Japanese Black P... (0) 1 cy"1 Vie: 61 - ■■ — tF is JF } Keyboard shortcuts Map data ©2022 Imagery ©2022, Maxar Technologies, U.S. Geological Survey Terms of Use Attachment 4 PLN2022-0033 MONARCH TRE E SE RVICES # Species Health Objective 42 Acer macrophyllum 13"-18" 80% - Good Bigleaf Maple 46'-60' 43 Acer macrophyllum 13"-18" 80% - Good Bigleaf Maple 46'-60' 44 Alnus rubra 7"-12" 40% - Poor Removal -Cut to Grade Red Alder 31'-45' 45 Acer macrophyllum 13"-18" 80% - Good Clearance Removal Cut 0.5" dia. / Clearance Removal Cut 1" dia. / Crown Raise / Bigleaf Maple 46'-60' Deadwood Removal greater than 1" 46 Pseudotsuga menz... 19"-24" 80% - Good Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Douglas Fir 60+ 47 Acer macrophyllum 13"-18" 80% - Good Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Bigleaf Maple 46'-60' 48 Tsuga heterophylla 19"-24" 60% - Fair Deadwood Removal greater than 1" / Monitor -Future Removal Western Hemlock 60+ 49 Tsuga heterophylla 19"-24" 60% - Fair Deadwood Removal greater than 1" / Monitor -Future Removal Western Hemlock 60+ 50 Tsuga heterophylla 13"-18" 40% - Poor Removal/Flush Cut Western Hemlock 46'-60' 51 Tsuga heterophylla 7"-12" 20% - Critical Removal/Flush Cut Western Hemlock 31'-45' 52 Tsuga heterophylla 19"-24" 60% - Fair Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Western Hemlock 60+ 53 Acer macrophyllum 13"-18" 80% - Good Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Bigleaf Maple 46'-60' 54 Tsuga heterophylla 19"-24" 60%- Fair Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Western Hemlock 60+ 55 Tsuga heterophylla 19"-24" 60%- Fair Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Western Hemlock 60+ 56 Tsuga heterophylla 19"-24" 60%- Fair Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Western Hemlock 60+ 57 Tsuga heterophylla 7"-12" 60% - Fair Western Hemlock 60+ 58 Pseudotsuga menz... 19"-24" 80% - Good Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Douglas Fir 60+ 59 Pseudotsuga menz... 19"-24" 80% - Good Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Douglas Fir 60+ 60 Pseudotsuga menz... 19"-24" 80% - Good Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Douglas Fir 60+ 61 Pseudotsuga menz... 19"-24" 80% - Good Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Douglas Fir 60+ Attachment 4 PLN2022-0033 MONARCH TREE S E R Woodbridge Apartment Map Satellite I - WT;�%'w 0 :: Legend(81) r L J Douglas Fir (6) ��... —Atlas Cedar (5) ' ��•; v�-. ' - Western Hemlock (1) ;-� Vine Maple (7) .a Bigleaf Maple (0) Red Alder (0) �� •: - _r-�'K. Pacific Madrone (1) . t- ` ,�' `J`•� r� `• �• Lodgepole Pine (0) •%>' s Scouler Willow (0) 81 Pacific Dogwood (0) ly so e z Maple Species (0) 79•e Japanese Floweri... (0) tL Japanese Black P... (0) 78 + �• PI S�-r 76 r.; 76' 73 72' Ai 70 r� 63 1 64 68 01 V. Keyboard shortcuts Map data ©2022 Imagery ©2022 , Maxar Technologies, U.S. Geological Survey Terms of Use Attachment 4 PLN2022-0033 # Species 62 Pseudotsuga menz... Douglas Fir 63 Pseudotsuga menz... Douglas Fir 64 Pseudotsuga menz... Douglas Fir 65 Pseudotsuga menz... Douglas Fir 66 Cedrus atlantica Atlas Cedar 67 Pseudotsuga menz... Douglas Fir 68 Pseudotsuga menz... Douglas Fir 69 Arbutus menziesii Pacific Madrone 70 Acer circinatum Vine Maple 71 Acer circinatum Vine Maple 72 Tsuga heterophylla Western Hemlock 73 Acer circinatum Vine Maple 74 Cedrus atlantica Atlas Cedar 75 Cedrus atlantica Atlas Cedar 76 Acer circinatum Vine Maple 77 Cedrus atlantica Atlas Cedar 78 Acer circinatum Vine Maple 79 Cedrus atlantica Atlas Cedar 80 Acer circinatum Vine Maple 81 Acer circinatum Vine Maple Health 19"-24" 80% - Good 60+ 19"-24" 80% - Good 60+ 19"-24" 80% - Good 60+ 19"-24" 80% - Good 60+ 13"-18" 80% - Good 46'-60' 7"-12" 80% - Good 46'-60' 7"-12" 80% - Good 46'-60' 13"-18" 80% - Good 3 V-45' 7"-12" 90% - Very Good 16'-30' 7"-12" 90% - Very Good 16'-30' 7"-12" 40% - Poor 60+ 7"-12" 90% - Very Good 16'-30' 13"-18" 80% - Good 46'-60' 13"-18" 80% - Good 46'-60' 7"-12" 90% - Very Good 16'-30' 13"-18" 80% - Good 46'-60' 7"-12" 90% - Very Good 16'-30' 13"-18" 80% - Good 46'-60' 7"-12" 90% - Very Good 16'-30' 7"-12" 90% - Very Good 16'-30' MONARCH TRE E SE RVICES Objective Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Building Clearance / Clearance Removal Cut 0.5" dia. Building Clearance / Clearance Removal Cut 0.5" dia. Deadwood Removal greater than 1" / Monitor -Future Removal Building Clearance / Clearance Removal Cut 0.5" dia. Clearance Removal Cut 1" dia. / Crown Raise / Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Clearance Removal Cut 1" dia. / Crown Raise / Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Building Clearance / Clearance Removal Cut 0.5" dia. Clearance Removal Cut 1" dia. / Crown Raise / Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Building Clearance / Clearance Removal Cut 0.5" dia. / Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Clearance Removal Cut 1" dia. / Crown Raise / Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Building Clearance / Clearance Removal Cut 0.5" dia. / Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Building Clearance / Clearance Removal Cut 0.5" dia. / Deadwood Removal greater than 1" Attachment 4 PLN2022-0033 MONARCH T R E E SE RVI C E b Woodbridge Apartment M' Y .1 l 0044 Legend(81) Douglas Fir (0) Atlas Cedar (0) Western Hemlock (0) Vine Maple (0) Bigleaf Maple (0) Red Alder (0) Pacific Madrone (0) Lodgepole Pine (1) Scouter Willow (0) Pacific Dogwood (0) Maple Species (0) Japanese Floweri... (0) Japanese Black P... (0) Keyboard shortcuts Terms of Use Attachment 4 PLN2022-0033 # Species 82 Pinus contorta Lodgepole Pine Health 7"-12" 60% - Fair 46'-60' Objective Deadwood Removal greater than 1" MONARCH TRE E SE RVICES Attachment 4 PLN2022-0033 Replanting Plan :�;�% Tree Quantity: 3 �'40 April 27, 2022 M O N A RC H T R E E S E RVI CES Proposal #: 377354 Tree Care Service Address/Location Tree Care Service Billing Address Monarch Tree Services - Washington Woodbridge Apartment Guide Property Services Monarch Landscape Company 21006 83rd Ave W 400 N. 34th Street, Suite 206 , Washington Edmonds, Washington 98026 Seattle, Washington 98103 Ralph B. Dobson Ilya Matvy ISA certified Arborist PN-6357A ilya@guidepm.com TRAQ Certified ralph.dobson@monarchlandscape.com tel:206-300-6211 Species City Height DBH Service Western Red Cedar 3 1'-15' 1"-6" Proposal #377354 Page 1 Attachment 5 PLN2022-0033 ., MONARCH Woodbridge Apartment •� Legend (3) Map Satellite y/ • Western Red Ceda... (3) T 1•, r, ■■ z'fiEa ... ❑'I Keyboard shortcuts Map data ©2022 Imagery ©2022 , Maxar Technologies, U.S. Geological Survey Terms of Use Proposal#377354 Page 2 Attachment 5 PLN2022-0033 CITY OF EDMONDS 121 5th Avenue North, Edmonds WA 98020 Phone: 425.771.0220 • Fax: 425.771.0221 • Web: www.edmondswa.gov DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DEPARTMENT • PLANNING DIVISION `ne. I STJ May 31, 2022 Ralph Dobson ralph.dobson@monarch landscape.com On behalf of Woodridge Edmonds, LLC 20904 83 Avenue W Subject: Tree Removal Request/Landscape Modification Mr. Dobson, Thank you for submitting a Landscape Modification permit requesting tree removals at the address shown above. Your request to remove 3 trees based on hazard tree criteria is approved for Trees: #38, 50 and 51. On -site observations confirm that 4 additional trees noted in the inventory as dead, dying, or poor condition (#23, 37, 41, 44) also fit hazard criteria and may be removed as well. Per ECDC 23.10.080.13, tree replacements are not required if the removed trees are hazardous, dead, diseased, injured, or in a declining condition with no reasonable assurance of regaining vigor. Since the 7 trees listed above fit those criteria and the site is heavily wooded, planting the 3 proposed Western Red Cedar replacement trees shown on the Replanting Plan is at the applicant's discretion. If you have any questions, please let me know at deb.powers@edmondswagov or 425-771- 0220. Sincerely, Deb Powers Urban Forest Planner Attachment 6 PLN2022-0033