Loading...
View Corridor Impact Study(2).pdfor - -- V Conclusion Meeting 12/13/10 ;M IK#J Summary: J011- 10 Studerit Tem Arnor Kool Base� Ismael Patrick McGlothlin Mardi Morrison Sean Beatty Introduction, Previous feasibility analysis conducted of the, Harbor Square property indicated that re -development of the site would be cost prohibitive under the Current density and' zoning restrictions,. Understanding this dilemma the! Port of Edmonds sought to ex�plore the possibility of adding density to the site through increased height limits. Because of the development sites location along the Edmonds waterfront the impact of such a sol ution needed to be carefully analyzed, The goal for the student team was to assess the impact of increasing the development height limits (above 35ft) associated with the Harbor Square property on the views currently enjoyed by neighboring property owners. Each member of the student Awxf Ah I "I'll, - AM 0, F-rdre WNIN 1. 1 00000 tt R master's degree in construction management at the University of Washington. Methodology Moving Forward - 61111ll 1,100111pi 016 1 WROGN inisliata 10-RITOM) �Vej$ ano Can rt�-rjn we•f1lul »Tecls I I frf the potential development in the future. The idea is that these simulations, can be applied to the 5ccurate as the des�gn progresses. In addition as the viewshe;d analysis becomes more refined and is used in conjunction with accurate models of the proposed buildings the analysis maps may be used for community outreach necessary to allay any concerns associated with the impact of the proposed gtructures on the view of the waterfront. University of Washington team members, Amor Kool Hometown: Indore, India Education'- Bachelor of Architecture (6,Arch) from Rajiv Gandhi Technical University (RGTU), Bhopal, India (2007); M.S. In Construction Management candidate (2010). Experience: Amor Is a licensed Architect with Council of Architecture New Delhi India. He has worked as a consultant Architect in Indere and New Delhi and Project Architect with RGAPL Noida, India, Amor's experience varies from interiors, residential, hotels and conservation and preservation. He worked as an assistant Architect in "Integrated development of Destination Patiala" documenting heritage buildings (Forts, tombs and Palaces) and proposing solutions for their conservation. Apart from that Amor has worked as a consultant and construction manager for an Interior of an apartment In New Delhi. In addition to working with several International Architectural consultancy firms as well, Currently he is conducting, research that compares projected energy models with actual performance of buildings as a thesis for Master's Degree In Construction Management at UW, Basel ismall Hometown' � Damascus, Syria Education: B.S, in Landscape Architecture from the University of Washington (2007): M.S. in Construction Management candidate (2010). Experience: Previously Basel worked in an environmental' art firm in Seattle from 2008 to 2009. He also was a teaching assistant in the department of landscape architecture at the UW for a computer aided drafting (CAD) class, Basel is proficient with several CAD, GIs and 3D modeling software applications, as, well as architectural rendering, graphic design, and photography means and methods, Mardi Morrison Hometown,, Silver Spring, MD Education, B.S. In, Finance, M.S. In Urban Studies, M.S, in Real Estate candidate 2011 and M!, S. in Construction Management candidate 2611.. Experience: Mardi has been actively Involved in urban redevelopment projects that have resulted in broad-based community benefits, property redevelopment, and re -energizing local business activity. Mardi has worked with the Milwaukee Department of City Development and the Real Estate Authority for the City at Milwaukee (RACM) on several commercial district revitalization initiatives where his contributions helped in the repositioning and redevelopment of a number of underutilized commercial properties fie has collaborated with Local Initiatives Service Corporation (LISC) in Milwaukee, resident associations, Milwaukee Main Street Program managers, community development corporations, and Business Improvement District (BID) leaders, In addition Mardi has also worked for several Fortune 500 companies helping to craft short and long-range strategic plans, Patrick McGlothlin Hometown,, New Castle, IN Education, B.S. In Architecture from the University of Cincinnati (2!004); M.S.in Construction Management candidate (2010) Experience,, Patrick has worked in a variety of architecturai/design firms since graduating from the University of Cincinnati in 2004. His, project experience ranges from the development of a modern pre -fabricated housing system while working in Minneapolis, MN to producing construction document sets for homes In Telluride, CO and large educational fadfitles in Cincinnati, OH. Currently he is working part-time for a small residential design/build firm in a construction management capacity. Sean Beatty Hometown: Fairfax, Virginia Education: Master of Architecture, Washington State University (2006), M.S. Construction Management candidate (2010), Experience: Upon graduating from WSU Sean took the opportunity to Intern with the US State Department; working at the London, UK embassy for 3 months, During this time he provided schematic design assistance for a renovation of the onsite pub; in addition to digitally mapping government real estate assets utilizing Google, Earth, After this Internship Sean took a position as a broker's assistant at Marcus and Millichap, In Seattle during this time he providing research and support for commercial real estate transactions throughout the Puget Sound region. After one year at Marcus and Mitlichap, Sean took a position with David Vandervort Architects in Seattle. Here he was involved with the, design and construction of custom single family homes with a focus on sustainability. Currently Sean Is a full time student at the University of, Washington who spends most of his free time remodeling a small craftsman home in Seattle. 11 AA A" Ifs la, 16,0, .,, �" A"" N" ji, Nt U& v^ w 6 01 "I lk 0�, *J4 If! L dil "0 4 . . . ............ . . ..... Harbor Square View Corridor Impact Study 11/22/10 Conducted by Students at the Unu versitIr ington on behalf of the Port of Edmonds Fall 2010 Faculty Advisor: John Schaufelberger student Team Arnor Kool Basel Ismael Patrick McGlothlin Mardi Morrison Sean Beatty Harbor Square View Corridor Impact Study Faculty AdvEsor 11/22/10 John Schaufelberger Conducted by Students at the University of Student Team Washington on behalf of the Port of Edmonds Amor Kool Fall 2010 Basel Ismael Patrick McGlothlin Mardi Morrison Sean Beatty 1=01 , In 1978 the Port of Edmonds acquired a parcel of land near the waterfront in downtown Edmonds. This parcel is bounded by Edmonds Way (51 1 04) to the, Nast, Dayton Ave to the North, Burlington Northern Railroad to the West, and the Edmonds marsh to the South, The sites area is roughly 14.62 acres of level ground that is irregularly shaped with respect to its property lines. In 1980 the site was re -zoned allowing for the introduction of mixed use, retail, office, and light industrial component% with a maximurn height limit of 35W In 1982 the port entered into a ground lease and development agreement with a loca,l developer that led to the construction of the structures Currently located onsite between 1982-1985. Known as 'Harbor Square' the current collection of nine buildings includes retail space, a hotel, and athletic club. Purchasing the leasing agreement back from the local development agency the port has been exploring re -development options for the site in order to increase the properties net operating income (NO[). Currently the site is experiencing a relatively high vacancy rate (+/-25%) and an effective NOI of $563,863 which places the investment value of the property using a 7.5% CAP rate at roughly $7.5million.11 While the hotel holds a long term lease and would be unaffected by any redevelopment proposal the remaining structures located onsite are potential candidates for redevelopment, Existing Site Platy (FIGURE 1.11 Redevelopment scenarios created for the port in 5/2010 to determine the financial viability of such a project demonstrated that under the current height limits of 35ft it would be financially impractical to redevelop the site even if the leasable space onsite was increased by 25,,00OSF. The failure for the project to perform financially despite the increase in leasable area is due primary to the high cost of construction 026.2 rnillion)and amount of debt still Outstanding on the property ($8.2 million)."" Understanding that any future redevelopment schemes for the site would be greatly enhanced by the ability to increase the effective density of the parcel; the port has solicited help from the University of Washington (UW) to study the impact of increasing the sites density. One of the primary methods for this added density would come from the introduction of increased height limits for structures located onsite to 65ft. The aforementioned redevelopment scenario completed earlier this year postulated thatincreasing the potential height limits onsite to 5 stories or roughly 65ft would allow future development options to become financially feasible. This assumes that market conditions were correctly analyzed and the new program would attract tenants for residential, commercial, and retail components. While the Success of any new development will depend on a variety of factors this report is focusing on the impact created by the introduction of increased height limits onsite (from 35ft to 65ft) to the surrounding communities view of the Puget Sound and offshore islands, West of the site. Aerial Photograp/7 (FIGURE 1.2) TOPOgraphiC Map 10'117tefVals (FIGURE 1,3) Parcel map (FIGURE 1.4) I eiW""Ilgillllirilli Iwo ls ,I I I LO 11000 1 2521TATZ Mgt] @J Or -Am IVA I WOT 14VIONIFARAM-1; Shaded Topographic Map (FIGURE 1,5) Many properties on the' estern side of this ridge take advantage of the views looking over the Puget Sound and offshore islands. The purpose of this study is to assess the impact of increasing the development height limits associated with the Harbor Square property to the views Currently enjoyed by neighboring property owners. Understandably property owners may object to development schemes located on the waterfront which may impact the views currently afforded to then. Understanding these sensitivities the port has commissioned a group of graduate students at the University of Washington to conduct research detailing the impact (if any) of redeveloping the Harbor Square property with increased heights, of 65ft. Vie sed Analysis Source of Data The source of topographic information used to conduct the viewshed analysis was Lidar, an airborne laser scanning technology. Lidar is often the source of topographic information used in Gl:!S databases. When the initial pass of airborne "Lidar' scanning is completed, the data collected is called 'first return." The first return data contains elevation coordinates for anything on the ground surface at the time of the scan, including trees, buildings, vehicles, e,tc. Typically, the first return data is processed to eliminate all of the non -topographic information from the scan and create a clean representation of the bare ground surface. For the purpose of this analysis, we chose to utilize this first return data to understand how the elements currently in existence on the ground plane were impacting views of the Harbor Square development site. This inclusion of not only the topography, but also trees, buildings and other elements ,allows for the realistic analysis of existing view corridors within Edmonds. EUEM a ammrs. namm Initially we explored importing the clean topographic data (geography only, no buildings, trees, etc.) culled from the Lidar survey with generic building masses extruded to the appropriate height allow within their zoning designation. This data was good for visualizing basic building and zoning locations within the downtown core (Figure 1, 6) but makes the impact of future development problematic to analyze within the model. The primary reason for this is that there is a great deal of information absent from the model (trees, vehicles, fences, etc,) which impacts the view corridors. For this reason we elected to analyze the various locations using the 'first return' Lidar data that includes ail of the objects located on the ground plane, this gives an accurate analysis of the conditions currently onsite without the need for extensive 3-D modeling and recreation of the site in digital format. The Observer points' tool within the ArcGIS software package was used to generate Our analysis, This tool is used to analyze visual exposure. It is a simple binary analysis for a defined observation point showing which points in a given area are visible from a given location, As displayed in the maps, points that are visible from a given location are highlighted on the map in blue. Any areas out of view remain white/fight gray on the map, For the purpose of this study, we defined a generic hypothetical structure on the Harbor Square property that represents a 'worst case' development scenario. This hypothetical structure borders the entire Northern and Eastern sides of the site and is 65' in height, It is important to note that this mass does not represent any design proposal for the property, but merely illustrates the potential impact a 65' structure could have on the surrounding view points. Each observation point was defined by selecting a point on the Lidar data surface and assigning the camera location to 6' above the Ground plane; representing the view height of an individual walking on the ground plane, In addition to the simulated view shed analysis performed utilizing the first pass Lidar data we elected to document each of the various locations with a panoramic image. These irnages help to reference the location and also give comparison to the digital data compiled at the same location, The chart below lists the locations of analysis with their corresponding latitude and longitude coordinates along with their offset from the ground plane. It should be noted that while point 28 says that its offset from the ground plane is only 3' this is actually the offset from a point above the ground plane (tree) so that the actual offset above the ground plane is actually 22' for this point. a This data is also available on a Google Earth file (.km) that illustrates the corresponding view location on a map as well as noting the coordinates associated with each point. A screenshot of this information can be found at (Figuiv 1.T) and the file entitled (Edinonds—view—points.kmz) is uploaded to the FTP site at Makers Architects. MUMUTEMUMMUM When reading and interpreting the viewshed analysis maps produced, it is important to keep a couple of factors in mind. First, the result of this analysis answers a simple and specific question: Can any portion of the hypothetical 65' structure be seen from the specified observation point? If the answer is yes, the pixel is blue, if the answer is no, the pixel is white, as described above. Second, the map is in no way quantifying the extent to which the view from each observer point is impacted, with the exception of the points that are not impacted at all (a,k,a, the hypothetical building mass is not highlighted blue), These viewshed maps may best be utilized as a representation of which area and observation points will not be impacted by the proposed project and which points should receive further review the extent of potential impact. Observation Point �O+l/ Hypothetical A 65 -ft Structure 'x Visible Area Development Area Acknowledgements: The UW student tearn would like to thank the following individuals for their efforts producing this report: John Schaufelberger; Chairman and professor of construction management at UW Kernan Lien; Edmonds Planning Department Phil Lovell; UW liaison Bob McChesney; Port of Edmonds John Owen; Makers Architects Stefani Wildhaber;, Makers Architects Rachel Miller, Makers Architects The Port of Edmonds; commissioners and staff. 3 JMfflnMmVM,MMMHMEZMJMM= Amor Kool Hometown: Indore, India Education'- Bachelor of Architecture (B.Arch) from Rajiv Gandhi Technical University (RGTU), Bhopal,, India (2007); M.S. In Construction Management candidate (2010). Experience: Amor is a licensed Architect with Council of Architecture New Delhi India. Ide has worked as a consultant Architect in Indore and New Delhi and Project Architect with RGAPL Noida, India. Amor's experience varies from Interiors, residential, hotels and conservation and preservation, He worked as an assistant Architect In "Integrated development of Destination Patiala" documenting heritage buildings (Forts, tombs and Palaces) and proposing solutions for their conservation. Apart from that Amor has worked as a consultant and construction manager for an Interior of an apartment in New Delhi. In addition; to working with several International Architectural consultancy firms as well. Currently lie is conducting research that compares projected energy models with actual performance of buildings as a lhesis for Master's Degree in Construction Management at UW. Basel Ismail Hometown: Damascus, Syria Education., B,S. in Landscape Architecture from the University of Washington (2007); M,S, in Construction Management candidate (2010). Experience: Previously Basel worked In an environmental art firm in Seattle from 2008 to 2009. Fle also was a teaching assistant in the department of landscape architecture at the UW for a computer aided!, drafting (CAD) class. Basel is proficient with several CAD, GIS and 3D modeling software applications, as well as architectural rendering, graphic design, and photography means and methods. Mardi Morrison Hometown: Silver Spring, MID Education' - B.S. in Finance, W& in Urban Studies, M.S, in Real Estate candidate 2011 and M,S, in Construction Management candidate 2011, Experience: Mardi has been actively Involved In: urban redevelopment projects that have resulted in broad-based community benefits, property redevelopment, and re -energizing local business activity. Mardi has worked! with the Milwaukee Department of City Development and: the Real Estate Authority for the City of Milwaukee (RACM) on several commercial district revitalization Initiatives where his contributions helped in the repositioning and redevelopment of a number of underutilized commercial properties. fie has collaborated with Local initiatives Service Corporation (LISC) in Milwaukee, resident associations, Milwaukee Main Street Program managers, community development corporations, and Business Iniprovernent District (BID) leaders. In addition Mardi has also worked for several Fortune 500 companies helping to craft short and long-range strategic plans. Patrick McGlothlin Hometown: New Castle, IN Education: B. in Architecture from the University of Cincinnati (2004)„ M.S. in Construction Management candidate (2010), Experience, Patrick has worked in a variety of architectural/design firms since graduating from ffie University of Cincinnati in 2004. His project experience ranges from the development of a modern pre -fabricated housing system while working in Minneapolis, MN to producing construction document sets for homes, in Telluride, CO and large educational facilities in Cincinnati, OH. Currently he is woriOng part-time for a small residential designibuild firm; in a construction management capacity, Sean Beate Hometown: Fairfax, Virginia Education: Master of Architecture, Washington State University (2006), M.S. Construction Management candidate (201 O). Experience: Upon graduating from WSU Sean took the opportunity to intern with the US State Department working at the London, UK embassy for 3 months. During this time he provided schematic design assistance for a renovation of the onsite pub: in addition to digitally mapping government real estate assets utilizing Googte Earth. After this Internship Sean took a position as a broker's assistant at Marcus and Millichap in Seattle; during this time tie providing research and support for commercial: real estate transactions throughout the Puget Sound region. After one year at Marcus and Milfichap, Sean took a position with David Vandervort Architects in Seattle. Here he was involved with the design and construction of custorn single family homes with a focus on sustainability. Currently Sean is a full time student at the University of Washington who spends most of his, free time remodelling a small craftsman home in Seattle. LION study, 5/2010 LMN study, 5/2010 NI LMN Study, 5/2010 3 I I Fa 11 a 0 WIN um MILO R 01 M 0 ca CL I AV a w Z P LO 11 C) a . . . .. . .. .... ... W V V I V 4! I 5eltii h mt j5 r1 04 -Z q M, 0 $0 mi no Lid w 51 m � 51 51 W 1] N 41 5 0 0 0 Is 0 4— 0 cr I LL kx 5eltii h mt j5 r1 04 -Z q M, 0 $0 mi no Lid w 51 m � 51 51 W 1] N 41 5 0 0 0 Is 0 4— 0 cr I LL 0 0 9 I 0 cu Cr s/ I CL E 9 rn ez Aran splualwpi 8 5 aAV 416 V E 0 "0 o C) W co rn ez Aran splualwpi C) V E 0 "0 o C) W co 0 I Ell S OAV 416, ot, ri 41, YN S DAV Paz a 0 I Ell C14! s av q16 W ILA, A* 4 MIN �'T Op or 8 0 k kms, 0 y mnR ilk 5 SmK S RAV PfJZ 0 co C- 0 E -a Lu 0 .t-- 0 m 5 OAV 416 VI 0 Arts qq ai 0 0 JK - X, pw 0 N't jy 0 S OAV PUZ 0 lip 00 i ADM sl .... . ... . ... am C- 0 E -a Lu 0 .t-- 0 m VI C- 0 E -a Lu 0 .t-- 0 m 1 k-4 Sim, S OAV 916 0/4" CL E 0 lik, CO lo -Vial 1— ii 8t s.UJ 0 qj* l pie S:OAVPU4 Ol wv rry I Int Kf oAjq ul c I I m I kr L, ZM= U) t 0- E 0 0 C) 0- U) 0 El 9 S OAV'416 i tl 0 S 04V puz 0 a L, ZM= U) t 0- E 0 0 C) 0- U) 0 El Ell qoj W6 10 w 16,4 '1, ,41, 0 El 13 Alim IP41OWPI CD 0 E pp qq- 0 r.L E7.7 as 410 I owyl a 44 0 5 QAV Peg w 16,4 '1, ,41, 0 El 13 Alim IP41OWPI CD 0 E pp qq- 0 r.L E7.7 as w 16,4 '1, ,41, 0 El 13 Alim IP41OWPI CD 0 E pp qq- 0 r.L E7.7 Y E AMY' S DAV 416 aiA All 11" j ko' WW 'Ile 0 s 41T fig 0 0 0 AoM 41109 wp3 (3) 70 U) CIL E 0 _0 0 a) =3 0- U) 0 0 E -0 uj 0 CL Fm E aiA *�' WW (3) 70 U) CIL E 0 _0 0 a) =3 0- U) 0 0 E -0 uj 0 CL Fm mm 0 E L _0U 14- 0 m W cn X1:0 N', wr ier CL E ON co 0 Ol S �Ay 416 ao-"1419 0 ro r,t,, .... . .... RM 17 104 PC a A. smv Puz AoM sptroLup3 Fa mm 0 E L _0U 14- 0 m W cn X1:0 N', wr ier CL E ON co 0 Ol 0 lie pq 0 SOAVPUZ 0 11 0 n T C-) S OAV q16 Ell Ell NE, t S DAY 416 f .9 10 4 Ip J, 04 OIL S OAV PUZ 0, a xam 1puawp] NE, rs as f NE, N o 5 Qq 116 C", LD Sq MY N;r1y cQr Ung z iy 0 0 tltlt Sam 0 0 SOWPUZ 0 a Q W M Asaph spuowpl Ili-," ai 1675 (IC) ren 15 kUT e, p a our QAC" o S QAV 416 co kkk. E Pgwvrc 0 . INOV � A Xm <.4 0 cr 1 e „� R 5"AW I 0,4 �uR d ww rm,� pA0 T OAV p'ulz ' � kin j Aufi � r Cp • as �- r„r.. yu .rw e.x r W .,. dK7 Co 0>V F 1 1 �� is "Ill�lp RCP �'�tl � (Y (I 4' i o tlI! E -a Lu Fm Mu awl $ S OAV FU7, 0 E -a Lu Fm w U) cu OL E 0 _0 0 co 07 U) 0 ca :E E -01 W! '4- 0 E Aw", 401 a 41 �1"v IN y sqqp 0 ry P't oiHv pug 0 0, AOM ipuowpl w U) cu OL E 0 _0 0 co 07 U) 0 ca :E E -01 W! '4- 0 E A S OAV 416 10 ON, 1P 4+Y 1L 41 0 a $DAvptjz a Ni AOM, ipuowpl _0 CL NZ, E CBS III 6 5 OAV 416 011 12 Novi he Or w a Marr 011 12 011 I E li EM 0 Ifw 1d $ $4 qis Ole pig 0 Is - - --------- ------- E li EM 0 cq cq E 0 _0 0 1> 12 cu cr COO L" 0 10 CD/ Fxx cq cq E 0 _0 0 1> 12 cu cr COO L" 0 10 aw cm co CL. E C7 ca 3: 414 ww Ov 0 illo LLI V— , 0 t -n- *AV pliz 0 a i6 0 CT AaM spowpi AQ 7-5 mE CO . . .. ...... m 8 Cq M U., M E 0 pp cr 0 E A S a AV q16, ri JIO 44 Ilk Sre,Fy NCS C"4 k S 4AV POI 0 AOM sp m 8 Cq M U., M E 0 pp cr 0 E o S OAV 416 ug a 1, %k' f: Q ("'J 0 N M 01 pn'N NOM llf� �ql 1, 00" SOAV Put 0 it NNI a 1, %k' f: Q ("'J 0 _0 04 cq U) $ uAv q16 E 0 cu 0 Povvi 0 cr W y011 100 70 UJ 0 le 4 tlA Itf 0 1� I a- > q PIT NN, vyr Ur 4"1 ild cW 6T 4* 104S C'o C �lo o S RAIV 4 16 a �P�Wjjl� 0 MAY w 01 s olv lip i Ov PIC Ul) jo 0 ADM spuamp] . ........ . . ... 4* 104S C'o C =3 C04 i.7; 4— E T3 �E 0 C) aw goo A Cc: E uj CL 0 S OAA PUZ 0 M111"',-�IJ to*. 7$ CL E 0 C) 3: (D (D co :3 Cr U) 0 E -a w 1� 0 = t, 0 a. rz- 4f1 S OAA PUZ 0 M111"',-�IJ to*. 7$ CL E 0 C) 3: (D (D co :3 Cr U) 0 E -a w 1� 0 = t, 0 a. A CO "j CO cq cri E 0 o a) Cu cr U) 0 E 00 Q') ADM A CO "j CO cq cri E 0 o a) Cu cr U) 0 E 4� U) co Cl. E co 0- 0 -0 i— co El aAW PUZ 0 0 AOM Spot 4� U) co Cl. E co 0- 0 -0 i— co El CC) fl -1) Q 73 4- C) CL E 0 a) co U) 0 -0 MA 0 E -a Lu 4-- 0- 0 CL, R." la MOO 4' NO, S DAV PUZ 0 41" AAM SF CC) fl -1) Q 73 4- C) CL E 0 a) co U) 0 -0 MA 0 E -a Lu 4-- 0- 0 CL, R." 4— U) E #1 U) E III 70 6 -- W I'm ADM 1p ell ...... . .... 441 t„w dY. 4— U) E #1 U) E III 70 6 -- -3 o S QAY t116 CL (D SIN IMP CU cr (j) LIJ IMd f C) INV[ S OAV PUZ 0 Au Vm qwawpi IT, Ills, an 01 F5 21 cl) a6 0I kPi > mum 4 as Ow ol mum 4 SOAypuZ 0 a spun, . ........... CO) c1l) U) 76seg M E I.- 0 (D CU E Ow ol pr j, f", T SOAypuZ 0 a spun, . ........... CO) c1l) U) 76seg M E I.- 0 (D CU E mRW Ell 0 I ol spuotUP3 W 0 E _0 w 0 11-. OL 'Ell eAv pot aNp 'AO Ell 0 I ol spuotUP3 W 0 E _0 w 0 11-. OL 'Ell #IV 44 co I wn 41 IR 7D 0 44 tf 40 ah 0 s OV puz 0 A.ApooWPI til 171� 10 t (J) -L- co z 0 Zr (C) a s QAV 416 cy 0 V) _0 c 0 E _0 Lu 4-- 0 tf , 0 ; 0- Mpp 9. Q of S OAV puz 0 Au ipuawpl cy 0 V) _0 c 0 E _0 Lu 4-- 0 tf , 0 ; 0- S a4v '1 $6 51k 0 D 4� 0L E 0 0 C) a) cr U) L-. 0 -0 2 Ell CO CL E 0 0 C.) Cr U) L- 0 n cu a-_ 0, S UAV 446 L 00 ADM sp�1ao11'YP3 mm sa am CO CL E 0 0 C.) Cr U) L- 0 n cu a-_ 0, s C� rp A, E 0 "a 0 0 Z: 0- U) t- 0 C'u E _0 W 0 0 S -vol 0 0 pNj i MAT Iq s OAV puz 0 a All, C� rp A, E 0 "a 0 0 Z: 0- U) t- 0 C'u E _0 W 0 I S OAV IM I At CA4 E 0 0 C) 3: Q) U) 0 .jo 2 ICU M iii 10 14 IPA C 0 E _0 iW I'le IRE I At CA4 E 0 0 C) 3: Q) U) 0 .jo 2 ICU M iii C 0 E _0 #AV 416 0 SAreVv4 cr U) 5 M V9 0 E tae LO 0 If CL r AaM 6PUOWP3 ell) co ,Xrr S ell 1 �A r Ee,Mia : 'W'" Cul NJ 1i14 Ilk, fa -,to C "J 4,1 JON W CL. Wq: 41 "I TOO am spuowpl C "J W CL. I W E 70 w 0 ,LD tiro Ili I W E 70 w 0 ,LD EZ U) CO -0 c 0 E �n wi 4- 0 CL CN a 5 OAV 446 co cr 0 R ply �4 I Ply r to 70 U.j 0 lq V 0 CL > i Ov P4 LO A*M spummp] ca Z' IE CL E 01 CA UC) 10 "a ,J