2023-12-14 Historic Preservation Commission MinutesCITY OF EDMONDS
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
Summary Minutes of Regular Meeting
December 14, 2023
CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL
Chair Vogel called the meeting of the Edmonds Historic Preservation Commission to order at 5:33 p.m.
He read the mission statement and the land acknowledgement and led the Pledge of Allegiance.
Commissioners Present
Larry Vogel (Chair)
Katie Kelly
Tim Raetzloff
Sam Spencer
Commissioners Absent
Chris Deiner-Karr
David Preston
MINUTES
Staff Present
Amber Brokenshire, Associate Planner
Mike Clugston, Senior Planner
Others Present
Michelle Thompson, CLG Coordinator, DAHP (online)
Councilmember Chris Eck (online)
1. Approval of November 9, 2023 HPC Minutes
The November 9, 2023 HPC minutes were approved as presented.
PUBLIC HEARING
A. Public Hearing on 116 Fourth Avenue North Historic Nomination
Associate Planner Amber Brokenshire made the presentation on 116 Fourth Avenue North. She reviewed the
location, designation criteria, and the home's association with a historic person in the community (F.R. Beeson).
The Commission expressed interest in also getting the Beeson building which was constructed by F.R. Beeson
on the Register. Ms. Brokenshire reviewed some issues with the integrity of the home and explained staff
recommends that the Commission find the nomination meets the criteria for potential designation in the
Edmonds Register of Historic Places because the house is "associated with the lives of persons significant to
local history". It doesn't need to meet all the other criteria. It is still a good representation of original construction
within Edmonds.
Historic Preservation Commission Meeting Minutes
December 14, 2023
Pagel of 3
Chair Vogel pointed out the significance of this home being downtown and on the 46'Avenue cultural corridor.
He spoke to Beeson's importance to the town as a mayor, councilmember, etc. and the fact that he built the
Beeson building.
The Commission asked Michelle Thompson's opinion about the style of the home. Ms. Thompson said in her
opinion it would be either "no style" or "eclectic'.
It was moved and seconded to recommend approval of the house at 116 at 116 Fourth Avenue North for
the inclusion on the Edmonds Register of Historic Places. Motion passed unanimously.
Nathan Monroe, owner of the home, said it was an honor for the home to be on the Register. He appreciates the
recognition.
Councilmember Eck agreed with the recommendation.
b. Public Hearing on 100 Fifth Avenue North Historic Nomination
Ms. Brokenshire made the presentation on 100 Fi$h Avenue North. She reviewed the location, designation
criteria, and the building's association with the early commercial development within Edmonds. Staff
recommended that the Commission find the nomination meets the criteria for potential designation in the
Edmonds Register of Historic Places.
Chair Vogel commented on the importance of this building as a community hub since it was originally the
grocery store. It was one of the first Safeway branded stores, and it also held the post office. The parapets were
removed since the original construction, but Commissioner Raetzloff thought they were removed over 50 years
ago. Chair Vogel noted it is in the center of Edmonds at 5t1i and Main Street. It was noted that this was right at
the point where a historic district would be.
It was moved and seconded to recommend 100 Fifth Avenue North for the Edmonds Register of Historic
Places. Motion passed unanimously.
Councilmember Eck agreed with the recommendation and said she loves the building and thinks it represents
the heart of downtown Edmonds.
REQUESTS FROM THE AUDIENCE
Nathan Monroe expressed appreciation to the group for their work.
NEW BUSINESS
Mission Statement
It had been requested by Commissioner Preston that the mission statement be added to the top of the agenda.
Ms. Brokenshire explained they had missed the deadline for tonight's agenda, but it will be added going
forward.
Historic Preservation Commission Meeting Minutes
December 14, 2023
Page 2 of 3
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Chair Vogel noted that the newsletter distribution box in Yost Park had run out of newsletters but more have
been printed by Ms. Brokenshire. He is very pleased that people are taking them and apparently reading them.
Chair Vogel asked for an update on plaques. Ms. Brokenshire said is looking into vendors and if the state grant
funding will cover the plaques. Chair Vogel suggested using some kind of temporary signs if they can't get
plaques in a timely manner. It would be nice to give people something as soon as their home is approved.
Commissioner Kelly said it could be as simple as a yard sign with a QR code. She also noted that in the past the
City had provided a post for some people who didn't want to put the plaque on their house. That may be another
expense that needs to be considered.
Ms. Brokenshire suggested having a discussion about how calendars should be distributed/allocated in the
future. Chair Vogel recommended having two or three main distribution points downtown such as the log cabin,
and City Hall and then walking around and giving a few to various businesses in the historic district area. They
could also put out a press release with a notice that people could go get copies at the City Hall or the log cabin.
They may want to look into ordering more next year if budget allows since there is a big demand for them. Ms.
Brokenshire recommended beginning to think about the 2025 calendar soon.
COMMISSION CHAIR COMMENTS
Chair Vogel thanked everyone for being part of the group and expressed appreciation for working together over
the year. He wished everyone a happy holiday.
COMMISSIONER COMMENTS
Commissioner Kelly wished everyone happy holidays.
Commissioner Raetzloff thanked Commissioner Spencer for bringing energy to the Commission.
Ms. Brokenshire thanked everyone for their time and attention to this Commission. Happy Holidays and Happy
New Year.
Commissioner Spencer said it was a dream come true for him to be part of this commission. He has a goal of
putting ten new homes on the Register next year.
ADJOURNMENT
The meeting was adjourned at 6:25 p.m.
Historic Preservation Commission Meeting Minutes
December 14, 2023
Page 3 of 3