2016-01-06 Civil Service Commission MinutesEDMONDS CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION
MINUTES
CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING
Regularly Called Meeting
January 6, 2016
Commissioners present: H. Scott McEwen, Chair
Mike Fields
Commissioners absent: Norm Davis
Others present: Assistant Chief of Police Jim Lawless
Secretary & Chief Examiner Mary Ann Hardie
CALL TO ORDER
Chair Scott McEwen called the meeting to order at 7:00 pm. Commissioner Norm Davis was unable to attend the meeting
MINUTES — December 2, 2015
Commissioner Fields made a motion to approve the meeting minutes of December 2, 2015. Commissioner
McEwen seconded the motion. The motion carried.
CORRESPONDENCE
• Letter from Corporal Ken Crystal requesting the Commission consider not certifying/reconsider approving the
extension to the Sergeant Eligibility List (from the December 2, 2015 meeting)
Corporal Ken Crystal recalled last year the commission did not approve his request to change the testing date. His
argument at that time as well as today was the benefit provided by a larger pool of candidates. There are now additional
officers eligible/interested in taking the test. In response to Commissioner McEwen, Corporal Crystal said he was not
aware of the December 2, 2015 meeting. Corporal Crystal referred to an email he received regarding today's meeting. Ms.
Hardie described the notification and posting procedure for Civil Service Commission meetings.
Discussion followed regarding concern with setting a precedent if the commission makes a decision at a meeting and
reverses it at a subsequent meeting. Ms. Hardie clarified the email was sent at Chief Compaan's request, inviting
department members to make him aware of any concerns so they could be presented to the commission.
Sergeant David Machado did not recall receiving notification related to the December 2, 2015 Civil Service Commission
meeting or that it would include a request to extend the Sergeant Eligibility List. Had he been notified, he likely would have
brought it to Corporal Crystal's attention and may have attended the meeting himself. He was forwarded an email, which
he believed was provided to all commissioned staff members, bringing attention to today's meeting and specifically this
issue on the agenda. As a nearly 27-year member of the department, he said in the past extension of promotional lists
was always notably advertised beyond the legally required notification. He understood the concern with changing the
commission's decision and suggested the suitable action at the December 2, 2015 meeting may have been to seek input
from officers affected by the decision. He assured his comments were related to process and had nothing to do with
Corporal Froland who requested the list be extended or with Corporal Crystal. He urged the commission to reconsider
because specific notification/advertisement of the meeting was not provided as has been done in the past as well as the
fact that more people testing is good for the department.
Sergeant Mike Richardson said he receives an email every month about the Civil Service Commission meeting.
Corporal Alan Hardwick said extending the list upon request is normative; usually an extension is granted when
requested. He feared setting a precedent whenever someone did not want the list extended and how would that be
decided. To the argument that adding applicants to the pool would provide opportunity for the best candidate, he pointed
out the list contains five eligible candidates. He also noted the list can only be extended for one year.
Chair McEwen said this issue has arisen several times during his 11 years on the commission and he did not recall not
approving a request for an extension. He also recalled in the past anyone who objected to the extension was present at
the meeting to provide input to the commission.
Commissioner Fields advised the December 2, 2015 meeting was noticed as required by law and the commission heard
testimony from those present. He envisioned changing the commission's decision could be problematic in the future.
Commissioner Fields made a motion that the Extension of the Sergeant Eligibility List stand as approved at the
December meeting. Commissioner McEwen seconded the motion. The motion carried.
POLICE BUSINESS
Certification of the extension of the Sergeant Eligibility List to ex ire on February 11. 2017 as approved by the
Commission at the December 2, 2015 meeting
See motion above.
Review and approval of the Entry Level Police Eligibility List
ACOP Lawless advised the Entry Level Police Eligibility List has been updated to include the top 20 candidates. He
advised the #2 person asked to be withdrawn so the list actually includes 19 names. He advised two candidates,
Nathaniel Bickley and Brittney Johnson, have been hired so they no longer appear on the list. The department currently
has no openings.
Review and approval of the Lateral Level Police Eli ibilit List
ACOP Lawless reviewed the Lateral Level Police Eligibility list, advising one person was disqualified following background
and one person previously on the list has been hired.
Commissioner Fields made a motion to approve the Entry Level and the Lateral Level Police Eligibility Lists.
Commissioner McEwen seconded the motion. The motion carried.
NEW BUSINESS
Review/approval of proposed draft language to the Civil Service Rules and Re ulations (Chapter 2- Attendance b
speakerphone or video)
Ms. Hardie recalled Commissioner Davis inquired about commissioners attending meetings via phone or video. The
practice in the past has been to reschedule meetings when scheduling conflicts arise. Commissioner Fields expressed
concern with commissioners not getting a sense of the meeting when participating by phone/video. He preferred to
continue the current practice of rescheduling meetings when necessary. Chair McEwen agreed. It was agreed to table this
item to the next meeting to allow Commissioner Davis to comment.
OTHER
The meeting adjourned at 7:33 pm
McEwen,
a•3-%w
Mary Ann Hardie, Secretary and Chief Examiner
Date
2